Best Engagement Rings Under $500: Beautiful Budget Options
This post may contain affiliate links. Read our affiliate policy
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.
A meaningful engagement ring doesn't require a massive budget. With $500 or less, you can find beautiful rings that sparkle brilliantly and last a lifetime. The key is knowing where to allocate your budget—and today's options include moissanite, lab-grown diamonds, and stunning gemstone alternatives that look far more expensive than their price tags suggest.
This guide helps you navigate the best choices under $500. For more budget options, see our engagement rings under $1000 guide, and for complete buying advice, visit our engagement ring guide.
What $500 Can Get You
The under-$500 category has transformed thanks to high-quality alternatives:
| Stone Type | Carat Size | Setting | Typical Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moissanite | 1-2 ct | Sterling silver | $100-300 |
| Moissanite | 1-1.5 ct | 14K gold plated | $150-400 |
| Lab-grown diamond | 0.25-0.40 ct | Sterling silver | $300-500 |
| Natural sapphire | 0.5-1 ct | Sterling silver | $150-400 |
| Morganite | 1-2 ct | Rose gold plated | $100-350 |
| CZ (cubic zirconia) | 1-3 ct | Sterling silver | $30-150 |
Best value: Moissanite offers the most impressive appearance per dollar—you can get a 1.5+ carat stone with excellent sparkle for under $300.
Best Options Under $500
Moissanite Rings
Moissanite is the standout choice for budget engagement rings. This silicon carbide gem offers:
- More brilliance than diamond (higher refractive index)
- More fire (rainbow sparkle)
- Excellent durability (9.25 Mohs—suitable for daily wear)
- Ethical sourcing (lab-created)
- Remarkable affordability
What to look for:
- D-F color equivalent (colorless)
- VVS clarity
- Excellent or Ideal cut
- Reputable seller with good reviews
Budget breakdown:
| Budget | What You Get |
|---|---|
| $100-200 | 1 ct moissanite, silver setting |
| $200-300 | 1.5 ct moissanite, gold-plated setting |
| $300-400 | 1-1.5 ct moissanite, halo style |
| $400-500 | 2 ct moissanite or solid gold setting |
For more comparison, see our moissanite vs diamond guide.
Lab-Grown Diamond Rings
Lab-grown diamonds are chemically identical to natural diamonds—same sparkle, same hardness. Under $500, expect smaller stones, but they're real diamonds.
What you can find:
- 0.25-0.40 carat round brilliant
- Simple solitaire settings
- Sterling silver or gold-plated bands
Pros:
- It's a real diamond
- Certified quality available
- Ethical and sustainable
Cons:
- Smaller sizes at this price point
- Limited setting options
See our lab-grown vs natural diamond guide for details.
Gemstone Alternatives
Colored gemstones offer unique beauty and excellent value:
Blue Sapphire
- 9 Mohs hardness (extremely durable)
- Royal heritage (Princess Diana's ring)
- Natural stones affordable under $500
- Beautiful blue catches light differently than white stones
Morganite
- Romantic pink-peach color
- Beryl family (like emerald)
- Pairs beautifully with rose gold
- Large stones affordable
Aquamarine
- Serene light blue
- March birthstone
- Very clear stones available
- Excellent durability
White Sapphire
- Diamond alternative
- Natural white stone
- Very affordable
- Less sparkle than moissanite but more "natural"
Setting Styles Under $500
Solitaire
The most affordable setting option. A single stone on a simple band costs less than styles with accent diamonds.
Budget-friendly solitaire tips:
- Choose a 4-prong setting (less metal = lower cost)
- Sterling silver keeps costs down
- Focus budget on the stone quality
Halo
Surprisingly affordable with moissanite or CZ accent stones. The halo makes your center stone look 30-50% larger.
Why halos work on a budget:
- Small accent stones are cheap
- Creates impressive visual impact
- Center stone can be smaller
Three-Stone
Available under $500 with moissanite or gemstones. The symbolic "past, present, future" meaning adds significance.
Metal Options Under $500
Sterling Silver
- Most affordable precious metal
- Can tarnish (easily cleaned)
- Often rhodium-plated for brightness
- Good for starter rings or placeholder rings
Gold-Plated
- Sterling silver core with gold layer
- Looks like solid gold initially
- Plating wears over time (1-2 years)
- More affordable than solid gold
10K Gold
- Solid gold at lowest karat
- More durable than higher karats
- Available under $500 for simple styles
- Investment in real precious metal
Platinum-Plated
- Sterling silver with platinum coating
- Bright white appearance
- More durable plating than rhodium
- Hypoallergenic surface
Quality Considerations
What to Prioritize
- Stone quality — A well-cut stone makes the ring
- Setting security — Prongs should be solid
- Comfort fit — You'll wear it daily
- Reputable seller — Good reviews and return policy
What to Accept at This Price
- Silver instead of gold — Upgrade later if desired
- Smaller carat if choosing diamond — Quality over size
- Plated finishes — Plan for eventual replating
Red Flags to Avoid
- No return policy
- Vague stone descriptions
- "Diamond-like" without specifying material
- Prices too good to be true for claimed materials
- No customer reviews
Tips for Maximizing Your Budget
1. Choose Moissanite Over Small Diamonds
A 1.5-carat moissanite is more impressive than a 0.3-carat diamond at this price point. Moissanite's brilliance rivals diamond, and most people can't tell the difference.
2. Consider Sterling Silver
Sterling silver looks beautiful and allows you to invest more in the stone. You can always reset the stone in gold later.
3. Shop Online
Online retailers have lower overhead and better prices. Stick to reputable sellers with good reviews and return policies.
4. Look for Sales
Holiday sales (Black Friday, Valentine's Day, etc.) often offer significant discounts.
5. Consider Etsy Artisans
Independent jewelers on Etsy often offer excellent value with handcrafted quality and personalization options.
Upgrade Path
Many couples start with a budget ring and upgrade later. Consider:
Placeholder proposal — Propose with an affordable ring, then shop together for an upgrade.
Stone reset — Keep the stone, reset into better metal later.
Anniversary upgrade — Plan for a 5 or 10-year anniversary ring upgrade.
Stack additions — Add wedding band and anniversary bands over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you get a real diamond for under $500?
Yes, but it will be small (0.25-0.40 carats for lab-grown). If size matters, moissanite offers much better value at this price point.
Is moissanite a good choice for an engagement ring?
Absolutely. Moissanite is extremely durable (9.25 Mohs), more brilliant than diamond, and will last a lifetime with proper care.
Will people know my ring was inexpensive?
Not unless you tell them. A well-chosen moissanite or gemstone ring looks stunning. Most people can't distinguish moissanite from diamond.
Should I feel bad about a budget ring?
No. The ring's meaning comes from the commitment it represents, not its price tag. Many happy marriages started with modest rings.
Can I upgrade the setting later?
Yes. Stones can be reset into new settings. Start with a quality stone in a simple setting, then upgrade the metal later.
Related Guides
- Best Engagement Rings Under $1000
- Complete Engagement Ring Guide
- Moissanite vs Diamond
- Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamonds
- Engagement Ring Settings Guide
1 Carat Round Moissanite Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
1 Carat Round Moissanite Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
A brilliant 1 carat moissanite in a classic solitaire setting.
A brilliant 1 carat moissanite in a classic solitaire setting. D color, VVS clarity for exceptional sparkle. Sterling silver band with platinum plating for durability.
"Our Pick - Maximum sparkle at an unbeatable price.
1.5 Carat Moissanite Halo Engagement Ring 14K Gold Plated
1 5 Carat Moissanite Halo Engagement Ring 14K Gold Plated
A stunning halo design that makes the center stone appear even larger.
A stunning halo design that makes the center stone appear even larger. The surrounding accent stones add incredible fire and brilliance.
"Best Value - Looks like a much more expensive ring.
Natural Blue Sapphire Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
Natural Blue Sapphire Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
A genuine natural blue sapphire in an elegant solitaire setting.
A genuine natural blue sapphire in an elegant solitaire setting. Sapphires are extremely durable (9 Mohs) and perfect for daily wear.
"Unique Pick - A colorful alternative with royal heritage.
Morganite and Diamond Halo Ring Rose Gold Over Silver
Morganite and Diamond Halo Ring Rose Gold Over Silver
Romantic pink morganite surrounded by a diamond halo in rose gold.
Romantic pink morganite surrounded by a diamond halo in rose gold. The warm tones create a distinctively romantic look.
"Romantic Pick - Perfect for those who love blush tones.
Review of Our Favorite 3
1 Carat Round Moissanite Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
A brilliant 1 carat moissanite in a classic solitaire setting.
1 5 Carat Moissanite Halo Engagement Ring 14K Gold Plated
A stunning halo design that makes the center stone appear even larger.
Natural Blue Sapphire Solitaire Ring Sterling Silver
A genuine natural blue sapphire in an elegant solitaire setting.
About the Author
Alfreda Borror
Alfreda Borror is an avid admirer of the finer things in life, and has an unending appreciation for luxury. Her considerable skills lie in design and fashion, having spent years working as a costume designer for both theatre and film.
